| Barefoot In the Park | November | 2017 |
| Oklahoma! | April | 2017 |
| When Radio was King | February | 2017 |
| BornYesterday | October | 2016 |
| The 39 Steps | April | 2016 |
| Cabaret | January | 2016 |
| Last Gas | October | 2015 |
| Grey Gardens | January | 2015 |
| The Miracle Worker | October | 2014 |
| Godspell | April | 2014 |
| Doubt | January | 2014 |
| The Wonderful Wizard of OZ | October | 2013 |
| Fiddler on the Roof | April | 2013 |
| Steel Magnolias | January | 2013 |
| Wyrd Sisters | October | 2012 |
| Moonlight and Magnolias | April | 2012 |
| You’re a Good Man Charlie Brown | January | 2012 |
| The Diviners | October | 2011 |
| Storybook Endings II | March | 2011 |
| Infidelities | January | 2011 |
| The Butterfingers Angel, Mary & Joseph, etc. | December | 2010 |
| I Remember Mama | March | 2010 |
| Love, Sex and the IRS | January | 2010 |
| Alice’s Return to Wonderland | October | 2009 |
| Storybook Endings | March | 2009 |
| Wit | January | 2009 |
| MCP Presents Sidecar Heroes | December | 2008 |
| Monmouth’s Got Talent | October | 2008 |
| The Little Shop of Horrors | March | 2008 |
| On Golden Pond | January | 2008 |
| All is Bright | November | 2007 |
| Monmouth’s Got Talent | October | 2007 |
| The Secret Garden | March | 2007 |
| The Graduate | January | 2007 |
| Picture This | November | 2006 |
| Monmouth’s Got Talent | October | 2006 |
| Into the Woods | March | 2006 |
| Sirens on Broadway | November | 2005 |
| 45 Seconds from Broadway | October | 2005 |
| Jekyll and Hyde | March | 2005 |
| Been There, Done That | November | 2004 |
| Cave Springs | October | 2004 |
| Bus Stop | March | 2004 |
| Camelot | November | 2003 |
| The View from here | March | 2003 |
| Joseph and the Technicolor Dreamcoat | November | 2002 |
| Anasazi | March | 2002 |
| Annie Get Your Gun | November | 2001 |
| Secret Garden | March | 2001 |
| That’s Entertainment | October | 2000 |
| One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest | March | 2000 |
| You Can’t Take it with You | October | 1999 |
| Cactus Charlies’s Wake | March | 1999 |
| Barrymore’s Ghost | September | 1998 |
| Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf? | March | 1998 |
| Annie | November | 1997 |
| On Broadway | September | 1997 |
| Cactus Charlies’s Saloon | April | 1997 |
| Dracula | November | 1996 |
| What’s in a Name | September | 1996 |
| Black Comedy | March | 1996 |
| Bye, Bye Birdie | November | 1995 |
| Broadway Past, Present, and Future | September | 1995 |
| Covington’s Cove | March | 1995 |
| Oliver | December | 1994 |
| An Evening with Disney | September | 1994 |
| The Scheme of the Driftless Shifter | March | 1994 |
| The Fantastiks | November | 1993 |
| Joseph and the Technicolor Dreamcoat | April | 1993 |